This lesson explores the definition and ideas of agnosticism as well as the specific sub-types. What does it mean to be an agnostic? How can other belief systems interact with agnosticism? Review the lesson and then follow up with a short quiz.
Coined by Professor Huxley at a party in London to found the Metaphysical Society in 1869, Huxley combined the a- prefix for ‘without‘ and -gnostic meaning ‘knowledge.‘ Agnosticism is an extreme empiricism view, which means we humans would never be able to know about the ultimate origin and causes of the universe. It is the act of questioning, doubting, or disbelieving in a higher order because it is impossible to know.George Smith put it well when he said, ‘Properly considered, agnosticism is not a third alternative to theism and atheism because it is concerned with a different aspect of religious belief.
Theism and atheism refer to the presence or absence of belief in a god; agnosticism refers to the impossibility of knowledge with regard to a god or supernatural being. The term agnostic does not, in itself, indicate whether or not one believes in a god. Agnosticism can be either theistic or atheistic.
Agnosticism is divided into different types based on what ideology it has been attached to.
‘I cannot know whether there is or is not a deity, and neither can you.
‘ To a Strong Agnostic, the world is only experienced through subjective experience and nothing is ever truly objective. Ultimate and true empiricism is impossible due to the fact that humans are inherently unable to see beyond their own limitations.
‘Maybe one day, we will know by proof if there is a deity.’ A Weak Agnostic holds the same idea as a Strong Agnostic (that we do not know if there is a deity) but allows for the possibility that man’s continual exploration and expanding knowledge may one day prove if there is or is not a deity.
‘I don’t believe in a deity, but I don’t know if there is one or not.
‘ An Agnostic Atheist acknowledges that there is no proof for or against a deity, but holds the belief that a deity does not exist.
‘I believe there is a deity, but I don’t know if there is one or not.’ An Agnostic Theist believes there is a deity, but acknowledges that there is no proof that any particular deity in the current or past religions is the actual deity.
Apathetic or Pragmatic Agnosticism
‘If a deity does exist, which there is no proof for or against, it is unconcerned with us.’ The Apathetic or Pragmatic Agnostic is similar to the idea of Deism, that a deity created the universe and set it in motion, then left it behind.
Agnosticism is not a third type of belief, opposite of atheists and theists. It is actually a philosophical stance that can be attached to any view of deity by acknowledging that humans cannot prove if a deity exists or not.
By attaching the agnostic view onto a person’s views and beliefs on the existence and nature of a deity, it creates multiple agnostic types.
After you are done with the lesson on agnosticism, you can pursue these goals:
- Decipher the term agnosticism
- Differentiate between agnosticism, atheism and theism
- List the various types of agnosticism and the ideologies they might be related to