This lesson reviews Rachel Carson’s classic ”Silent Spring”, which was published in 1962. Read on to analyze the book’s meanings and examine the impact it had on the pesticide industry in America.
We Live in a Beautiful Place
Have you ever stood up for something you knew was right, even if you knew you’d be ridiculed for it? Have you ever taken on something bigger than yourself? When Rachel Carson wrote and published Silent Spring in 1962, large corporations lined up to make sure her message was either not heard or was disregarded. But their efforts were in vain. Instead, actual environmental changes began to take place as a result of Carson’s hard work and perseverance.
Silent Spring brought environmental concerns – particularly about pesticides – to the forefront of the national consciousness. It invited questions from the public at large on issues that affected the future of the environment in the wake of pesticide usage.
Summary: What’s In the Water?
Silent Spring was the result of several different events that caused Rachel Carson to pay attention to the results of pesticides used to control insect populations in America following World War II. This image shows a World War II soldier being sprayed with the pesticide DDT in order to control lice.
Carson’s friend, Olga Huckins, wrote a letter to The Boston Herald describing the death of birds around her property after DDT was sprayed to control mosquitoes. This spurred Carson to look more deeply at the problem.
The research for Silent Spring took Carson four years to complete and led The New Yorker to request an in-depth analysis of pesticide usage in America. Carson considered asking other authors to collaborate with her on the project, but inevitably undertook it alone with only the help of her research assistant, Jeanne Davis. She provided evidence towards the correlation of cancer cases in combination with these chemicals, and touted the possibility of biological pest control. Carson was met with resistance from chemical companies and their lobbyists at every turn.
In Silent Spring, Carson attacks pesticides and notes their effects on ecosystems and species other than the pests they are meant to control. Their carcinogenic impact is explored, and she details the possible side effects that overexposure to the chemicals could cause. Carson discusses the tumors that had been found as a result of exposure, and scientific evidence that has been compounded in support of her theory.
Carson also explores the possibility that there will be pests that come along that could be resistant to the pesticides, and that the damage of the chemicals to the environment could aid in those resistant species taking over. DDT is not the only chemical to be examined in Silent Spring, but Carson called for a reduced usage of these compounds to avoid over-saturation of the ecosystems. She supported the usage of biotic as opposed to chemical pesticides, but did acknowledge the need for pest control.
Recoil and Impact
The chemical industry, including giants like DuPont, immediately began trying to disprove and disparage Silent Spring, putting out various propaganda to combat the impact that the book was having on people in America. Carson, who was undergoing radiation for breast cancer at the time, had to vigorously defend her research and conclusions.
Those who disparaged Carson would often misquote her – for instance by saying that she advocated halting the use of all chemical pesticides. This was false, as Carson actually stated that as little as possible should be used, or that alternatives should be explored. She never said not to use pesticides entirely. Carson also insinuates in Silent Spring that pesticides were profitable for the large corporations that sold them, and perhaps that overrode any concerns that arose with the usage of the products. As time has progressed, it has become more evident that sometimes this was truly the case.
Other scientists attacked Carson and her book as well. This did not hamper public opinion of Silent Spring, however. The public outcry over the information contained in the book led to the creation of the Environmental Protection Agency, or EPA, in 1970 by President Nixon, to balance the USDA and their advocacy of pesticides. This is the most lasting legacy of Silent Spring, along with the influence on countless conservationists that were impacted by Rachel Carson’s work.
Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring was the first of its kind, challenging the environmental impact of big business in America following World War II. The book addresses many of the concerns prevalent in studying the consequences of chemical pesticide usage, particularly in the case of the pesticide DDT. Carson is responsible for making us aware of the idea that these chemicals could have far-reaching ramifications later in time.